Dovetails - by machine or by hand?

Practice time for amateurs is the problem when it comes to perfecting hand tool techniques. There is no quick and easy method to make hand tool mortise & tenon joints, for instance. And once got wrong they’re near impossible to put right. One must begin again; and perhaps waste valuable wood.

There is a case for a half-way hoose. To make through wedged tenons as required in many A&C styles, I forego the mortise chisel in favour of downcut spiral router bit or a Domino XL. The tenons are easier to make by hand, with handsaws and a router plane.

Hand cut DTs are satisfying and, once the techniques are learnt, can be made surprisingly quickly. The right tools help - good quality saws and chisels, as well as accurate marking with a fine marking knife. Many chisels are poor at chopping out the waste, especially in small and closely-spaced DTs. A cheap & nasty saw just won’t cut a neat kerf to the marked line; and will leave a rough cut surface.

Nice DTs can be made with a machine. These were made with a woodrat and some of it’s teeny-weeny fine DT HSS cutters.

1 Like